Lesson Plan
Level / Stream | Secondary 3 Express Students of Mixed Abilities |
Learning Environment | ICT Resource Room or Computer Lab. Each student has access to a computer station to facilitate individual work concurrently. These computers should share a network which would allow the sharing of information and to enable the teacher to monitor and guide students’ activities. |
Lesson Prerequisites | Prior to the lesson, students need to have knowledge on: 1. Literary Devices 2. Themes |
Lesson Objectives | By the end of the lesson, the students/pupils will be able to: 1. Identify at least 2 literary techniques employed in the given and explain the effects of these literary devices on the poem as a whole. 2. Apply the literary devices and themes identified to the creation of their personal poem about their home country. |
Lesson Duration | 2 periods (60 min) |
Description of Instructional Strategies
Time | Description of Activities |
5 min
15 min
15 min
10 min
15 min | • Teacher briefly recaps previous lesson on themes and literary techniques like rhythm, rhyme, repetition etc.
• Teacher introduces the class to the http://typewith.me platform which is a collaborative text document that the students will use to record and share their responses while watching the videos. • Teacher will show the first version of the song “Empire State of Mind” by Alicia Keys. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iYmmh9zkpQM • Students are to record their responses to the song (emotions and thoughts) as they watch the video. • Teacher shows the second video, which is a segment of an episode of the television programme, Glee, where the cast performs the same song. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=APjJwt7rc6I&feature=related • Students are to record any changes in their response towards the same song performed in a different way: - The first is a sentimental version by Alicia Keys - The second version is a cheerful and vibrant version by the Glee cast • The students can respond to the comments made by their friends on this collaborative platform where they can type simultaneously.
• Students get into groups of 4 or 5 students each to prepare for the next group activity. • Teacher hands out the lyrics to the song “Empire State of Mind”. (Appendix A) • Students are to analyse the lyrics of the song, picking out the theme(s) of the lyrics. For example, inspiration, hope and pride etc. • They are also required to identify literary techniques employed in the lyrics and to explain the effects these techniques have on the reader. - Students can also include personal responses to the lyrics especially if they feel that they can connect to what is being illustrated in the song.
• Groups briefly share their analyses with the class.
• On an individual basis, students will create a short poem about their home country based on the context of the song “Empire State of Mind”. They are to include at least 2 literary techniques and a theme identified in their analysis of the lyrics of the song. |
Lesson Rationale
My teaching philosophy is inspired by my strong belief in that every child can be taught. Content knowledge should not be the only focus in education. In fact, learning should take place through one’s experiences because these are the fundamentals that shape a person.
As most of us would be familiar with “nature vs nurture”, the school environment is a social institution which should introduce real-life to students step-by-step, as argued by John Dewey. He also advocated that the “school is a form of community life in which all those agencies are concentrated that will be most effective in bringing the child to share in the inherited resources of the race, and to use his own powers for social ends”. This is the rationale behind my lesson activities. Instead of teaching content knowledge, I employ music as a tool in delivering my lesson. Music is known as a universal language, thus, it provides a platform for discussion which every child can draw connections to. By using a medium – popular culture – that is familiar to them, the students are able to understand the skills taught and commit them to memory.
The activities chosen also reflect Paulo Freire’s belief that dialogue is an existential necessity. He advocates that speech should be the right of every man and not just the privilege of a few men. The individual activity using typewith.me facilitates individual expression of their personal opinions and emotions, allowing those who have problems speaking up in class to voice their thoughts. Predominantly a student-centred lesson, the top-down approach is avoided, allowing more room for students to develop their viewpoints and illustrating Freire’s belief that speech should be the right of every man.
Appendix A
Oooh oooh, New York (2x)
Grew up in a town,
That is famous as a place of movie scenes
Noise is always loud
There are sirens all around
And the streets are mean
If I could make it here
I could make it anywhere
That’s what they say
Seeing my face in lights
Or my name in marquees found down Broadway
Even if it ain’t all it seems
I got a pocketful of dreams
Baby, I’m from
New York, concrete jungle where dreams are made of
There’s nothing you can’t do
Now you’re in New York
These streets will make you feel brand new
Big lights will inspire you
Hear it for New York, New York, New York
On the avenue, there ain’t never a curfew
Ladies work so hard
Such a melting pot on the corner selling rock
Preachers pray to God
Hail a gypsy cab
Takes me down from Harlem to the Brooklyn Bridge
Someone sleeps tonight with a hunger
For more than from an empty fridge
I’m going to make it by any means
I got a pocketful of dreams
Baby, I’m from
New York, concrete jungle where dreams are made of
There’s nothing you can’t do
Now you’re in New York
These streets will make you feel brand new
Big lights will inspire you
Hear it for New York, New York, New York
One hand in the air for the big city
Street lights, big dreams, all looking pretty
No place in the world that can compared
Put your lighters in the air
Everybody say yeah, yeah yeah
New York, concrete jungle where dreams are made of
There’s nothing you can’t do
Now you’re in New York
These streets will make you feel brand new
Big lights will inspire you
Hear it for New York
I liked this lesson :). I think the objectives are clear the steps of the activities are also clear and act as good scaffolds in allowing the teacher employing this lesson plan to achieve his or her objectives. The contrast between the two videos and versions of the song are good as firstly it shows the artiste performing the song so allows the students to be aware of the different moods and tone that can be created from the same lyrics but from different performance techniques. The rap version performed by the glee cast pays emphasis to rhyme (as most rap songs do), which can also help allow the students to understand how rhyme can contribute to tone and the meaning of the poem in general.
ReplyDeleteHowever a way in which this lesson can be improved is maybe showing the following video, which is the official music video of the song, Jay Z ft Alicia keys, http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0UjsXo9l6I8 as a third video or as a replacement to the glee version as it provides images of new york, which may also help students understand the imagery present in the lyrics that can also help set the tone and mood of the song.
Interesting lesson, Donna, though i'm not sure if your process and outcomes are essentially Freirean (that is, in line with his pedagogical doctrines in his book PEDAGOGY OF THE OPPRESSED)...
ReplyDeleteTo the extent that you want to encourage authentic personal responses from your students to the song lyric, you might also note the subjective and personal nature of your own interpretations (e.g. Alicia Keys version is "sentimental" while the Glee version is "cheerful and vibrant"). If you wanted to justify your personal interpretations, would you appeal to the literary qualities of the printed lyrics or the musical qualities of the songs?
To what extent are you requiring a MULTIMODAL analysis of the texts in question, rather than a conventional literary analysis?
Relatedly, what are the literary devices you want your students to see in "Empire State of Mind"? It's good for the teacher to have a set of "answers" ready at hand...